Geddry’s Newsletter

Geddry’s Newsletter

Epstein, Trump, and the Manufacturing of Silence

When power primes disbelief and makes speech expensive, opacity becomes policy, and exposure without accountability becomes routine.

Shanley Hurt's avatar
Shanley Hurt
Feb 06, 2026
∙ Paid

A tip is a strange kind of courage. Not the cinematic kind, not the kind that makes you feel brave. The kind that makes you feel sick, the kind that arrives with trembling hands and a dry mouth and the conviction that if you don’t say it out loud now, it will rot inside you forever. You don’t call the FBI because you feel powerful. You call because something feels wrong, because a memory won’t sit still, because a name you’ve carried in private has suddenly become public. You call because you saw a face in the news and your body reacted before your mind caught up, heart slamming like a trapped animal, hands going cold, metal in your mouth, time collapsing. You call because you’re trying, late and imperfectly, to protect someone else. You call because silence has started to feel like participation.

In the Epstein case, that kind of courage carries a weight most people can’t imagine. This wasn’t rumor. Jeffrey Epstein’s crimes were real enough to sustain prosecutions in Florida and New York. Real enough to convict an accomplice. Real enough that the government itself has said its review “confirmed that Epstein harmed over one thousand victims.” Over one thousand. Not a scandal, not a headline, a thousand separate nervous systems still bracing for impact. A thousand people whose bodies learned the same lesson: power can do what it wants to you, and you will be the one who has to keep living afterward.

Share

So, when the government announces it will release millions of pages of “Epstein files,” the public treats it like spectacle, like a name hunt, a dirty scavenger hunt for famous people. But if you are a survivor, you don’t hear spectacle. You hear a drawer being yanked open. You hear: We are going to make your pain searchable. You hear: We are going to turn the worst thing that ever happened to you into a public archive. And your first question isn’t “Who else is in it?” Your first question is smaller and more desperate:

Did anyone ever do their job? Did anyone listen when people tried to warn them? Did anyone connect the dots before more children were fed into the machine? Did anyone move fast enough to interrupt harm instead of documenting it afterward? Did anyone treat the girls, the coerced and cornered and groomed, as human beings and not as evidence?

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Mary Geddry.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Mary Geddry · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture